Under their tree, three fifteen-year-old girls, Keira, Zainab, and Lucy, wrestle with sex, shame, and growing up at different paces. It starts with a game and a dead possum. It ends with someone getting hurt.
Playfight unfolds like a story whispered in a forest at dusk. It is set in a world that feels almost enchanted, shaped by warm lighting, textured sound design, and a stage that looks as though it has grown up from the earth itself. Yet within this magical frame sits a narrative that is anything but gentle. The contrast is deliberate. The beauty of the setting softens the edges of a story that is raw, unsettling, and painfully familiar to anyone who remembers what it felt like to be young and unprepared for the world.
The script follows three girls, Keira, Lucy, and Zainab, who meet beneath an old tree over the course of a decade. They begin at fifteen, full of bravado, curiosity, and the kind of innocence that is already slipping through their fingers. The tree is both a literal and metaphorical anchor. It is their playground, their confessional, their shelter, and eventually the place where their understanding of intimacy and violence begins to blur. The staging makes this central symbol feel alive. A steel scaffolding trunk, woven flooring, and paper leaves overhead and littering the floor create a structure that feels warm and organic, almost protective. It is a magical space, but the magic is fragile.
The story moves quickly, flitting through time in short bursts that mimic the way memory works. One moment, the girls are laughing about school, the next, they are sharing secrets about sex, desire, and the confusing rules they are expected to follow. The pace mirrors adolescence itself. Everything changes fast. Everything feels enormous. Everything is both trivial and life-altering at once. The audience experiences these shifts the way the girls do, through casual conversations that suddenly reveal something shocking.
The performances are exceptional. Ana Chaya Scotnay’s Keira is brash, loud, and full of chaotic confidence. She recounts losing her virginity with almost no filter, and the humour of the moment is undercut by the uncomfortable truth beneath it. Liv Parker’s Lucy is restrained, Christian, and seeking validation, carrying her own contradictions with a softness that makes her later choices feel even more heartbreaking. Mirabai Pease’s Zainab is the sceptical, intelligent lesbian who slowly realises she has feelings for her friend. Her emotional clarity becomes a grounding force as the story grows darker.
The girls climb, swing, and circle the tree as they talk, their movements creating a sense of ritual. The staging is intimate and immersive, drawing the audience into the orbit of their friendship. The lighting shifts from warm golds to cooler, harsher tones as the years pass, and the sound design wraps around the space like a pulse. It is a world that feels enchanted, but the enchantment is always tinged with danger.
Thematically, Playfight is rich and unflinching. It tackles consent, pornography, societal pressure, religion, and the absence of safe spaces for young people to learn about sex. It never becomes moralistic. Instead, it presents ambiguity and asks the audience to sit with it. Was there consent? Are these girls happy, or are they performing happiness because they do not know what else to do? Are they making choices, or are choices being made for them? These questions linger long after the final blackout.
One of the most striking aspects of the show is that all major events happen offstage. We never see the acts of violence, the sexual encounters, or the moments that change the girls’ lives. We only see their reactions. Their attempts to make sense of what happened. Their confusion. Their denial. Their attempts to protect each other. This choice creates a buffer that prevents the audience from imposing their own biases. Instead of judging the events, we focus entirely on the girls and how they carry the weight of what they have experienced.
The script captures the volatility of adolescence with painful accuracy. The girls swing between confidence and insecurity, between bravado and fear, between loyalty and betrayal. Their emotional baggage grows heavier as the years pass, and each of them is shaped by their home life, their upbringing, and the expectations placed on them. The differences in how they respond to trauma are subtle but devastating.
As the story approaches its final stretch, the tone shifts into something almost feverish. The girls are heading towards twenty-four now, and the world feels sharper, faster, and more dangerous. Time has accelerated. Conversations become frantic. The magical setting begins to feel haunted. The play connects back to the real-world inspiration behind it, the aftermath of the "rough sex" defence, and the chilling implications of a society that leaves young people to figure out intimacy and safety on their own.
The final moments are unsettling, not because of what is shown, but because of what is implied. The innocence of the early scenes has been eroded. The tree that once felt protective now feels like a witness. The girls who once laughed beneath its branches now stand in the shadow of everything they were never taught to navigate.
Playfight is a powerful piece of theatre. It is beautiful, chilling, and deeply human. It captures the magic of youth and the danger of growing up without guidance. It shows how easily intimacy can blur into violence when no one teaches you how to look after yourself. And it does all of this through the eyes of three girls who are trying, failing, and trying again to make sense of a world that is far more complicated than they were prepared for.
It is a story that stays with you. Not because of what you saw, but because of what you felt.
Performance of Playfight run from 14-30 May at Auckland's Silo Hall
Purchase tickets here
Review written by Alex Moulton

















